Heated rivalry between characters on ice with a focus on Sapphic sports romance themes and fierce competition.

Books Like Heated Rivalry (But Sapphic): Must-Read Sapphic Sports Romance Books

Every now and then a Sapphic sports romance comes along that completely changes readers' expectations of a genre.

For hockey romance, that book was Heated Rivalry by Rachel Reid.

Book cover of 'Heated Rivalry' by Rachel Reid featuring two hockey players on a blue background.

Months after its release, readers are still searching for books that recreate the same feeling. Not necessarily because they want another MM romance, but because they're chasing the emotional experience that made Shane and Ilya's story impossible to forget.

It wasn't simply the hockey.

It was the rivalry.

The years of unresolved tension.

The secret relationship neither of them could risk exposing.

The undeniable chemistry that simmered every time they stepped onto the ice together.

The slow burn that rewarded readers with one of the most satisfying romances in modern sports fiction.

That's exactly why so many readers type phrases like books like Heated Rivalry,hockey romance recommendations or sports romances with rivals to lovers into Google. They're looking for stories that capture that same addictive combination of fierce competition, emotional vulnerability and characters who can't stop falling for the one person they're supposed to beat.

The good news?

Sapphic romance delivers those feelings exceptionally well.

Women's sports romance has quietly become one of the most exciting corners of LGBTQ+ fiction, bringing together elite athletes, professional rivals, teammates, Olympic hopefuls and fiercely competitive women who discover that the line between competition and attraction is far thinner than either of them expected.

Some stories unfold on professional hockey rinks where championships and careers hang in the balance. Others take place in colleges, national teams or amateur leagues where lifelong friendships slowly become something far more complicated. Whatever the setting, the best sapphic hockey romance books understand that sport is never just about winning.

It's about obsession.

Discipline.

Trust.

Sacrifice.

Learning to rely on someone when every instinct tells you they're your biggest rival.

Those themes create some of the most emotionally satisfying romances you'll find anywhere. Add locker-room banter, road trips, forced proximity, secret relationships and the intensity of elite competition, and it's easy to understand why sports romance has exploded in popularity.

Of course, hockey isn't the only sport producing unforgettable sapphic love stories. If you're looking to explore beyond the rink, don't miss my guide to the Best Sapphic Sports Romance Books, where you'll find footballers, boxers, climbers, mountain rescuers and plenty of fiercely competitive women finding love. And if it's the emotional payoff rather than the sport itself that keeps you turning pages, you'll also love my guide to the Best Slow Burn Sapphic Romance Books, featuring romances built on longing, chemistry and beautifully earned happily-ever-afters.

This guide focuses on the books that most closely recreate that irresistible Heated Rivalry feeling. Whether it's enemies-to-lovers tension, years of mutual pining, forbidden attraction, secret relationships or women determined to prove themselves on the ice, these stories deliver the same emotional rush that made Rachel Reid's novel such a phenomenon.

So lace up your skates.

Game time is about to begin.

Why Hockey Romance Creates Some of the Best Rivals-to-Lovers Stories

Two female basketball players standing face-to-face on an indoor court at night, with one wearing a black jersey with the number 27 and the other in a white jersey holding a basketball.

Few sports lend themselves to romance quite like hockey.

It's fast, physical and fiercely competitive. Players spend countless hours training together, travelling together and pushing each other to their absolute limits. Friendships form quickly, rivalries run deep and emotions are rarely left in the changing room. When attraction develops between two athletes, the stakes immediately become higher because every victory, defeat and selection suddenly carries emotional consequences beyond the scoreboard.

That's one of the reasons readers who loved Heated Rivalrycontinue searching for similar books. The romance wasn't compelling simply because Shane and Ilya played hockey. It worked because hockey naturally intensified every aspect of their relationship. Every match placed them on opposite sides. Every tournament forced them back into each other's lives. Every secret became harder to keep as their careers grew.

Sapphic hockey romance explores those same dynamics from a fresh perspective. Whether the characters are teammates fighting for the same position, lifelong rivals battling for championships or strangers thrown together by a new season, the emotional tension often feels just as exhilarating as the sport itself.

Many of these novels also explore themes that extend beyond the rink. Identity, confidence, coming out, career ambitions and balancing personal happiness with professional success all become central parts of the romance. That emotional depth is what transforms a good sports romance into one readers remember long after the final chapter.

If you enjoy romances built around fierce competition, you'll probably also love my guides to the Best Friends-to-Lovers Sapphic Romance Books and Best Age Gap Lesbian Romance Books, where emotional tension and unforgettable chemistry take centre stage in very different ways.

What Makes Rivals-to-Lovers Sports Romance So Addictive?

Two female hockey players facing each other on an ice rink, holding hockey sticks. One wears a black jersey with the number 17, and the other wears a white jersey with the number 12.

Some romance tropes come and go, but rivals-to-lovers never seems to lose its appeal. Whether the characters are battling for the same place on a hockey team, competing for a national title or simply refusing to admit how much they admire each other, there's something endlessly satisfying about watching fierce competition slowly transform into genuine affection.

That's one of the biggest reasons readers fell so hard for Heated Rivalry. Shane and Ilya weren't simply attracted to one another. They spent years trying to outplay each other, pushing one another to become better athletes while denying the feelings growing beneath the surface. Every game mattered because their personal lives were inseparable from their professional ambitions, creating emotional stakes that felt every bit as important as the final score.

The best sapphic sports romance novels capture that same emotional intensity. They understand that rivalry isn't built on hatred. It's built on respect. The women at the centre of these stories recognise each other's talent long before they admit their attraction, and that admiration creates chemistry that feels completely believable. Every challenge, every training session and every hard-fought victory becomes another step towards trust, making the eventual romance feel genuinely earned.

Many of these books also blend beautifully with some of Sapphic sports romance's most popular tropes. Forced proximity keeps athletes travelling together for tournaments and away games, while slow-burn attraction allows relationships to develop naturally over an entire season. 

Sport itself also provides the perfect backdrop for character growth. Elite athletes are driven, disciplined and often fiercely protective of the lives they've built. Falling in love means risking distraction, vulnerability and, in some cases, their carefully constructed public image. Watching ambitious women learn that success doesn't have to come at the expense of happiness is one of the reasons sports romance remains such a rewarding genre to read.

While hockey may have introduced many readers to Sapphic sports romance, these themes extend far beyond the rink. Basketball, boxing, football, tennis and countless other sports create exactly the same opportunities for unforgettable romance, proving that it's the emotional rivalry—not simply the game—that keeps readers turning pages long into the night.

Hoops and Heartstrings — Eliza Lentzski

Book cover for 'Hoops & Heartstrings' by Eliza Lentzski, featuring a basketball on a brown court background with white chalk lines and white title text.

If what you loved most about Heated Rivalry was watching fierce competitors slowly realise that the person they can't stop trying to beat might also be the one they can't stop thinking about, Hoops and Heartstrings is an excellent place to start. Eliza Lentzski swaps the hockey rink for the professional basketball court, delivering an emotionally satisfying rivals-to-lovers romance between two women whose shared history is as painful as it is impossible to forget. After a career-threatening injury leaves Lex Bennet playing alongside her former college rival, Eva Montgomery—the very woman she blames for changing the course of her career—the pair are forced to rebuild trust while chasing the same dream of professional success. As old resentments gradually give way to respect, friendship and undeniable attraction, the romance develops with all the emotional tension and slow-burn chemistry readers crave. Add in the pressures of professional sport, life in the public eye and Eva's struggle with coming out, and you have a heartfelt sapphic sports romance that proves love can flourish even between the fiercest of rivals.

Perfect for readers who love: rivals-to-lovers • professional basketball • former college rivals • forced proximity • teammates-to-lovers • coming out stories • slow-burn sapphic romance

The Clinch — Nicole Disney

Book cover of 'The Clinch' by Nicole Disney with a person wrapping boxing gloves.

If your favourite part of Heated Rivalry was the fierce competition between two athletes who can't stop pushing each other to be better, The Clinch delivers that same irresistible blend of rivalry, respect and simmering attraction. Nicole Disney trades hockey for the high-stakes world of mixed martial arts, introducing readers to reigning UFC featherweight champion Eden Bauer and rising challenger Brooklyn Shaw, whose confidence and undeniable talent make her impossible to ignore both inside and outside the cage. Their rivalry quickly becomes one of the biggest stories in the sport, but as the two women spend more time together, the tension between them begins to shift from professional competition to something far more personal. With championship dreams, public attention and years of sacrifice hanging in the balance, both women must decide whether they're willing to risk everything they've worked for in pursuit of love. Emotional, compelling and packed with authentic sporting intensity, this is a fantastic sapphic sports romance for readers who love rivals whose greatest challenge isn't winning the fight—it's admitting how they really feel.
Perfect for readers who love: rivals-to-lovers • mixed martial arts • UFC romance • elite athletes • fierce competition • slow-burn chemistry • emotionally rich sapphic romance.

Mistakes Were Made - Meryl Wilsner

Book cover of 'Mistakes Were Made' by Meryl Wilsner with two women at a bar.
  
If the secret relationship and impossible attraction in Heated Rivalry kept you turning pages long into the night, Mistakes Were Made delivers that same delicious feeling of two people who know they shouldn't be together but simply can't stay apart. Meryl Wilsner swaps the hockey rink for a wonderfully awkward, forbidden romance when college senior Cassie discovers that the incredible woman she shared a one-night stand with is none other than her best friend's mother. What begins as a mistake both women promise to forget quickly becomes impossible to ignore as stolen moments, growing affection and undeniable chemistry make walking away harder with every encounter. Balancing laugh-out-loud humour with genuine emotional depth, Wilsner creates two wonderfully relatable heroines whose connection feels both intensely romantic and refreshingly real. While this isn't a sports romance, fans of Heated Rivalry will recognise the same intoxicating blend of secrecy, longing and emotional tension that makes forbidden love stories so impossible to put down.
Perfect for readers who love: forbidden romance • age-gap relationships • secret relationships • one-night stands • emotional chemistry • witty romantic comedies • heartfelt sapphic romance

She Drives Me Crazy — Kelly Quindlen


Book cover of 'She Drives Me Crazy' by Kelly Quindlen featuring two girls in sports uniforms against a pink background.

If you loved the electric chemistry and emotional push-and-pull of Heated Rivalry, but you're looking for something lighter, funnier and packed with teenage charm, She Drives Me Crazy is an irresistible read. Kelly Quindlen brings the rivals-to-lovers trope to life through the story of basketball player Scottie Zajac and her long-time nemesis, head cheerleader Irene Abraham, whose worlds collide after an inconvenient car accident leaves them sharing rides to school every day. What begins as mutual irritation soon evolves into an elaborate fake-dating scheme designed to make Scottie's ex jealous, but the more time they spend together, the harder it becomes to tell where pretending ends and genuine feelings begin. Full of witty banter, heartfelt moments and wonderfully believable character growth, this YA sapphic romance proves that some of the best love stories begin with two people who can barely stand each other.

Perfect for readers who love: rivals-to-lovers • fake dating • high school romance • basketball romance • cheerleader romance • witty banter • heartwarming YA sapphic romance.

Like a Power Play — Elle Sprinkle

Book cover of 'Like a Power Play' by Elle Sprinkle featuring two women, a dog, and a hockey stick.

For readers searching for a sapphic romance that comes closest to the emotional intensity of Heated Rivalry, Like a Power Playshould be high on the list. Elle Sprinkle delivers everything sports romance fans love: elite college hockey, fierce competition, undeniable chemistry and two women whose first instinct is to challenge one another rather than fall in love. Peyton Clarke is determined to prove she's earned her place as Greenrock University's star centre on talent alone, despite growing up in the shadow of her famous NHL father. Darcy Cole, meanwhile, never expected to return to hockey after rheumatoid arthritis ended her own playing career, and she's less than thrilled to find herself working as the team's student assistant coach. Their opposing views on the game create immediate friction, but beneath the arguments and stubbornness lies a growing respect that slowly develops into something neither of them saw coming. Blending witty banter with heartfelt character development and an authentic love of hockey, this is exactly the kind of rivals-to-lovers romance that will appeal to fans looking for books like Heated Rivalry.
Perfect for readers who love: college hockey • rivals-to-lovers • coach and player dynamics • slow-burn romance • women athletes • emotional character growth • sapphic hockey romance.

Cleat Cute — Meryl Wilsner

Book cover of 'Cleat Cute' featuring two female soccer players on a field.

 If you loved the combination of elite athletes, fierce competition and irresistible chemistry that made Heated Rivalry so compelling, Cleat Cutedeserves a place at the top of your reading list. Meryl Wilsner swaps hockey for professional football, bringing together two talented players competing for a place on the US Women's National Team as the World Cup approaches. Grace Henderson has spent a decade at the top of her game, but after a serious injury she's forced to watch rising star Phoebe Matthews step into the spotlight. What begins as professional rivalry gradually evolves into friendship, flirtation and a friends-with-benefits arrangement that neither woman expects to become something far deeper. With sharp humour, heartfelt emotion and brilliantly developed chemistry, Cleat Cute perfectly balances the pressures of elite sport with a romance that's every bit as exhilarating as the action on the pitch. Fans of Heated Rivalry will especially appreciate the blend of ambition, vulnerability and slow-building emotional connection that lies at the heart of this standout sapphic sports romance.
Perfect for readers who love: professional football • elite athletes • rivals-to-lovers • teammates with chemistry • friends-with-benefits • World Cup setting • emotionally rich sapphic romance

Breakpoint — Candi Tab

Book cover for 'Breakpoint' by Candi Tab, featuring an illustrated tennis court scene with two female tennis players facing each other across a net, a yellow tennis ball in the foreground, and a pink-to-purple sky background.
If your favourite part of Heated Rivalry was watching two world-class athletes battle for supremacy before realising they might be exactly what the other needs, Breakpoint delivers that same addictive blend of rivalry, ambition and slow-burning attraction. Set in the fiercely competitive world of professional tennis, Candi Tab introduces readers to legendary champion Jazmine Mason, who has spent more than two decades dominating the sport, and Daniela Kappas, the fearless young star determined to take her place as America's number one. Their intense rivalry takes an unexpected turn when they're forced to compete together as a doubles team, transforming every practice session and every match into an emotional balancing act between competition and cooperation. As grudging respect develops into undeniable chemistry, both women are faced with an impossible decision: pursue the careers they've sacrificed everything for or risk it all for a love neither of them expected. Filled with sizzling tension, high-stakes competition and emotional depth, Breakpoint is an excellent choice for readers who love elite athletes, unforgettable rivals-to-lovers romances and characters who discover that the greatest victories don't always happen on the scoreboard.
Perfect for readers who love: professional tennis • rivals-to-lovers • age-gap romance • forced proximity • elite athletes • slow-burn chemistry • emotionally satisfying sapphic romance

Why Sapphic Sports Romance Is Winning Over More Readers Than Ever

Sports romance has always been about far more than the game itself. Whether it's hockey, basketball, football, boxing or tennis, the best sports romances use competition as a backdrop for stories about ambition, vulnerability and learning to trust another person. Every training session, every championship and every setback forces characters to reveal who they really are, making the emotional journey feel just as important as the final score.That's exactly why readers who finish Heated Rivalry often find themselves looking for more than simply another hockey romance. They're searching for stories where attraction grows through mutual respect, where rivals challenge each other to become better people and where love feels like another hard-earned victory.
Those themes aren't unique to hockey—they're at the heart of the very best sapphic sports romances.One of the biggest strengths of lesbian sports romance is the incredible variety of women at its centre. Some are seasoned professionals carrying the weight of championships on their shoulders. Others are college athletes trying to prove themselves, teenagers discovering first love or women rebuilding their confidence after injury and heartbreak. Their journeys may begin on different playing fields, but they all share the same determination, resilience and passion that make sports such a compelling setting for romance.
Readers also love the natural opportunities sport creates for romance to develop. Long road trips, intense training camps, shared locker rooms and the pressure of competing together all force characters into close proximity, allowing trust to grow one conversation, one practice session and one stolen glance at a time. Those quiet moments often become just as memorable as the biggest games.
If the emotional payoff is what keeps you reading, you'll also enjoy my guides to the Best Ice Queen Sapphic Romance Books and Best Sapphic Romance Books Made into TV movies where relationships are built gradually through trust, chemistry and beautifully developed character arcs.
And if you're looking for heroines who are every bit as driven and intimidating as elite athletes, don't miss my list of the Best Workplace Lesbian Romance Books, packed with ambitious women who slowly let the right person melt their carefully constructed walls.
Perhaps that's why sports romance continues to grow in popularity. Readers aren't simply looking for stories about winning championships. They're looking for women who refuse to give up on their dreams while discovering that success means far more when it's shared with someone who truly understands the sacrifices required to get there.
Whether your favourite stories unfold on an ice rink, a basketball court, inside a boxing ring or on a tennis court, one thing remains the same: there's nothing quite like watching fierce competitors become the very people who bring out the best in each other.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best sapphic hockey romance books?

If you're specifically looking for lesbian hockey romances, some of the very best include Like a Power Play by Elle Sprinkle, which combines college hockey with a slow-burn rivals-to-lovers romance, and several other emerging titles that continue to expand the genre. While sapphic hockey romance is still a relatively niche category, it's growing rapidly as more authors bring women's hockey to the forefront.

Are there books like Heated Rivalry with lesbian main characters?

Absolutely. While few books mirror Heated Rivalry exactly, novels such as Like a Power Play, Cleat Cute, Breakpoint, The Clinch, and Hoops and Heartstrings all capture many of the same themes, including elite athletes, fierce competition, emotional tension, slow-burn attraction and unforgettable chemistry.

Are sapphic sports romances spicy?

Many are. Books like Cleat Cute, Breakpoint, and Mistakes Were Made feature open-door romance, while others, such as She Drives Me Crazy, focus more on emotional connection and character development. Whether you prefer sweet romance or high heat, there's a sapphic sports romance to suit every reader.

What sports appear most often in sapphic romance?

Hockey and football are becoming increasingly popular, but readers will also find excellent romances set in basketball, tennis, mixed martial arts, baseball and other competitive sports. The best stories use sport as more than just a backdrop—they allow competition, teamwork and ambition to shape the romance itself.

What should I read after Heated Rivalry?

If you're chasing the emotional intensity of Heated Rivalry, start with Like a Power Play for another hockey romance, then move on to Cleat Cute, Breakpoint, and The Clinch. Together, they offer many of the same qualities readers love: fierce rivals, elite athletes, slow-burn chemistry and emotionally satisfying happily-ever-afters.

Conclusion

Whether it's hockey, football, tennis, basketball or mixed martial arts, the very best sapphic sports romances understand that the greatest love stories are built on more than attraction alone. They're about ambition meeting vulnerability, fierce rivals learning to trust one another and women discovering that sometimes the person standing in the way of their dreams is also the person they can't imagine living without.
If Heated Rivalry left you searching for another romance filled with unforgettable chemistry, emotional tension and characters willing to fight for both victory and love, these books deserve a place on your reading list. From college hockey to the World Cup, championship tennis courts to the UFC octagon, each of these stories proves that competition and romance make an irresistible combination.
And with more authors writing incredible sapphic sports romances every year, there's never been a better time to discover your next favourite rivals-to-lovers love story.

Continue Reading

If you enjoyed this list, you might also love:
Shopify banner with text 'Starting a store is easier than you think' and a call to action button.
Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Ruby Scott is a Scotland-based lesbian romance author. Two-time Lesfic Bard Award winner. Two-time Goldie Award finalist. Read more at rubyscott.shop.